honoluluadvertiser.com

Sponsored by:

Comment, blog & share photos

Log in | Become a member
The Honolulu Advertiser
Posted on: Sunday, July 5, 2009

UH involvement in undersea cable survey a good idea


By Jay Fidell

Under last year's Clean Energy Agreement, DBEDT has taken charge of the development of an undersea power line to carry 400 megawatts among four islands.

This cable will provide O'ahu with wind and solar energy from new renewable projects by David Murdock on Lana'i and First Wind on Maui and Moloka'i. It could go a long way toward reaching the goal of 70 percent renewables by 2030.

Using federal money, DBEDT is paying $1.5 million to the School of Ocean and Earth Science and Technology at UH to survey alternative cable routes and provide data for the forthcoming EIS.

The survey opens the way to a project that could change the face of energy in Hawai'i, and the stakes are huge.

SOEST HANDY

Although the ultimate contractor might have done this survey, along the lines of the "options" analysis done for rail by Parsons Brinckerhoff, given what we've learned from rail, SOEST, as a neutral party, might be a better choice.

SOEST already knows what's down there — it's been mapping the area for years. And SOEST has the equipment and research connections to take its data to a much finer resolution using cutting-edge sonar and video.

That considered, DBEDT did not hire SOEST through the state procurement process but treated it as a government agency under a sole source "intergovernmental services" contract.

The cable will be high voltage and nine inches wide. There aren't many such cables. Those in Long Island and Europe are in shallow water. In Hawaiian waters, this is a more challenging project and SOEST hopes to get it off to a good start.

HOW WE FIND OUT

SOEST will take its 223-foot research vessel, R/V Ka'imikai-o-Kanaloa ("Heavenly Searcher of the Seas"), on three trips — one 10-day trip for bathymetric depth measurement, one for videotaping (going on now), then one for coring samples. There is a scientific staff of 20, plus a crew of 13.

They use an underwater sonar scanning vehicle which trails one kilometer behind the ship. They also use other underwater devices, with thrusters and lights, to take video and get samples from the bottom.

SOEST will finish this field work this month and will deliver the data processing and reports to DBEDT in August. Based on this data, DBEDT will issue an RFP later this summer for an EIS and management of the larger project to follow.

OPEN QUESTIONS

  • Some wonder whether this cable is necessary and hope the state is looking into other island-specific alternatives, including more diverse renewables on O'ahu. That could be cheaper than the $2 billion we could spend on the cable.

  • Shouldn't Murdock and First Wind be paying for the cost of this cable when it is being built primarily to carry their renewables? Shouldn't we also be including the Big Island and Kaua'i and the renewables they can provide?

  • It's symbiotic — to work, the wind farms need the cable and the cable needs the wind farms. But wind is not firm, so this won't work unless someone also develops storage with pumped hydro, compressed air, batteries or otherwise.

  • With power on this scale, any problem could be huge. The routes must pass through the whale sanctuary — how will marine life be protected? What about seismic events and cable breaks? The jury is out until the EIS is done.

    ONE STEP FOR HAWAI'I

    All in all, this survey is a grand project for SOEST and the kind of due diligence that thrills the imagination. Graduate and undergraduate students are on the team and it's very exciting for them. They and the faculty are delighted to be involved.

    You've got to admire SOEST for being flexible and confident enough to jump in on a project like this. They have the science, the equipment and the people. They're doing it not only for the money, but also to make a contribution.

    Although larger commercial contractors will probably take over in the next step, to build our tech industry we should include SOEST and other local tech providers whenever possible.