honoluluadvertiser.com

Sponsored by:

Comment, blog & share photos

Log in | Become a member
The Honolulu Advertiser
Posted on: Thursday, September 10, 2009

'Season for action'

     • Islanders optimistic, skeptical


    By Chuck Raasch
    Gannett News Service

     • Hawaii lawmakers supportive
    Hawaii news photo - The Honolulu Advertiser

    President Obama told a joint session of Congress that he prefers to improve the current health care system "rather than build a new system from scratch."

    JASON REED | Pool photo via Associated Press

    spacer spacer
    Hawaii news photo - The Honolulu Advertiser

    The Republicans sit at right, and the Democrats stand and applaud at left. President Obama was interrupted repeatedly by applause in a chamber dominated by members of his own party.

    CHARLES DHARAPAK | Associated Press

    spacer spacer

    WASHINGTON — Scolding, cajoling and explaining, President Obama yesterday portrayed health care reform as a test of the nation's character, arguing that the status quo is unsustainable for both the economy and the well-being of millions of Americans.

    In a 50-minute speech to a rare joint session of Congress, Obama gave qualified support to his most controversial proposal, a government-run insurance option, while offering a modest olive branch to Republicans on medical malpractice reform.

    Obama offered no new sweeping plans, saying he prefers to improve the current system "rather than build a new system from scratch." That was a recognition of rising fear and doubts about his plan's scope and intentions, which Obama said had been whipsawed by "scare tactics" and rampant partisanship.

    The president tried to reassure seniors that cuts aimed at Medicare are aimed at waste, not their coverage.

    And he addressed two of the most contentious criticisms of his plan.

    He said the claim that he supports government "death panels" denying care for seniors is "a lie, plain and simple." Addressing another attack line, he said, "No federal dollars will be used for abortions."

    Some argue that Obama should have given this speech months ago, when Congress first began crafting reforms for an industry that encompasses one-sixth of the economy, and when he could have defined the debate before critics began picking it apart.

    One Obama line — "the plan I'm announcing tonight" — may seem belated and off-key after months of intensifying debate on his 10-year, $900 billion plan.

    Obama told Americans that any plan he signs will:

    • ban insurance companies from denying coverage because of pre-existing conditions;

    • prevent insurers from dropping or watering down coverage during illness;

    • end arbitrary annual or lifetime coverage caps;

    • limit out-of-pocket expenses;

    • require insurers to cover routine checkups, mammograms and colonoscopies.

    "I am not the first president to take up this cause," Obama said, "but I am determined to be the last."

    GOP SAYS START OVER

    Rep. Charles Boustany Jr. of Louisiana, giving the Republican response to Obama's address, urged Democrats to abandon their "government-run" approach and "start over."

    "Replacing your family's current health care with government-run health care is not the answer," Boustany said. "In fact, it'll make health care much more expensive."

    Boustany, a cardiovascular surgeon for more than 20 years, said "the president had a chance tonight to take government-run health care off the table. Unfortunately, he didn't do it."

    Most Americans want Obama and Congress to "start over with a common-sense bipartisan plan focused on lowering the cost of health care while improving quality," he said.

    'PARTISAN SPECTACLE'

    Obama said the health care system is at a "breaking point." He complained that while Congress was ready to pass about 80 percent of the reforms he wanted, the rest had been held up by "partisan spectacle."

    "The time for bickering is over," Obama said. "The time for games has passed. Now is the season for action."

    But in a sign of how far this plan is from passage, some lawmakers broke into laughter when Obama said there are "significant details to be ironed out." And in a breach of decorum that caused a gasp, a congressman in the audience shouted "You lie!" when Obama said that his health care reform proposal would not apply to illegal immigrants.

    Democrats cheered the loudest when Obama pointed out that he had inherited huge deficits from President George W. Bush. Republicans were the most enthused about tort reform.

    Obama tried to reassure those who already have health insurance, saying that "nothing in this plan will require you or your employer to change the coverage or the doctor you have."

    In defending the controversial "public option," Obama took a middle course. He said "it is only one part of my plan, and should not be used as a handy excuse for the usual Washington ideological battles."

    He told liberals that the public option is "only a means to an end," designed not to drive insurance companies out of business, but to "make coverage affordable for those without it." He told Republicans that "rather than making wild claims about a government takeover of health care, we should work together to address any legitimate concerns you may have."

    'WE WILL CALL YOU OUT'

    Obama said that doing nothing on health care would grow the deficit even more.

    "More families will go bankrupt," he said. "More businesses will close. More Americans will lose their coverage when they are sick and need it most. And more will die as a result."

    Obama is including a proposal from his Republican rival last year — to offer Americans who can't get insurance because they have pre-existing medical conditions low-cost coverage to protect them against financial ruin if they get seriously ill.

    Obama said it was a "good idea" when Sen. John McCain proposed it during the presidential campaign. He adds that it's still a good idea, and "we should embrace it."

    Amid applause from his colleagues, McCain smiled and gave Obama a thumbs-up.

    Obama, however, warned that he will not tolerate the strategy of "death by delay" articulated by some GOP strategists.

    "I will not stand by while the special interests use the same old tactics to keep things exactly the way they are," he said. "If you misrepresent what's in the plan, we will call you out."

    • • •

    KEY POINTS OF OBAMA'S PLAN

    Current coverage: Those who now are getting employer-provided coverage or are insured through Medicare, Medicaid or the Veterans Administration may be required to change their plans or their physicians.

    Cost: About $900 billion over 10 years.

    How it would be paid for: By finding "savings within the existing health care system," mostly by trimming waste and rooting out fraud.

    Health insurance exchanges: Consumers and small businesses without coverage could comparison shop. The exchanges would take effect in four years.

    Pre-existing conditions: Insurers could not deny coverage because of pre-existing medical conditions, nor cancel or dilute coverage when people get very sick.

    Affordability: No limits on how much coverage a consumer could get. Tax credits would be available for those needing aid.

    Preventive medicine: Insurers must cover, at no extra charge, regular preventive care and check-ups.
    Public option: People without coverage would be able to choose a not-for-profit government-run plan.

    Catastrophic insurance: Low-cost coverage would be available in the years before the exchanges are created
    in case of a serious illness.

    Individual mandates: Everyone would have to have basic insurance. Most businesses would be required to offer insurance or "chip in" to help cover workers.

    Medical malpractice lawsuits: The administration will seek experimental "demonstration projects" in different states aimed at helping to revamp the tort system.

    — Advertiser news services

    The Washington Post, McClatchy-Tribune News Service, Bloomberg News Service and Associated Press contributed to this report.